California Labor &
Employment Law Blog
SB 241: The Future of Virtual Courtrooms and the Impact on Employment Law
Sep 9, 2021

SB 241: The Future of Virtual Courtrooms and the Impact on Employment Law

Topics: Legal Information, New Laws & Legislation

Every court in California relies increasingly on remote video technology since the COVID-19 pandemic effectively closed courtrooms.  California’s Judicial Council adopted temporary emergency rules to assist courts providing access to justice during the pandemic.  As courts limited in-person hearings, remote proceedings became critical to the facilitation of civil litigation.  At the center of these virtual proceedings is Senate Bill (SB) 241, a draft bill authored by Senator Thomas Umberg, D-Santa Ana to authorize:

  1. Remote appearance by Parties,
  2. Allow all courts to conduct all hearings, conferences, proceedings, and civil trials with remote technology, and
  3. Witnesses to testify remotely under certain circumstances.

The bill provides that a court may require parties or witnesses to appear in person at a conference, hearing, or proceeding, in certain situations. 

While this bill will sunset 90 days after California’s COVID-19 Emergency Order is lifted, it could cause permanent changes to how many courts conduct business.  The most public opposition to the legislation is from labor unions representing court employees who fear that technology will decrease employment of their members and who claim that technological issues will lead to inaccurate transcripts and disadvantages to those without reliable internet access.  And, in cases requiring a translator, remote proceedings complicate the interpretation process even further.

On the other hand, state judiciary leaders and trial attorneys believe remote access is critical to reducing the courts’ tremendous case backlog.  Remote appearances allow cases to proceed faster, and litigants don’t have to miss work to travel to courthouses.

SB 241’s Potential Impact on Employment Litigation in California

As a result of COVID-19’s impact on business and resulting lay-offs, testing requirements and rapid changes to the workplace required by the CDC, Cal/OSHA and county health officials, California’s courts have seen an increase in employment claims.  Courts may be able to resolve a larger percentage of cases by conducting proceedings remotely.  Remote hearings save transportation time and costs for employment attorneys and their clients, and videoconferencing should increase the availability of witnesses for live testimony.  However, in-person trials increase settlement chances as the parties are faced with the inconvenience and pressures of open court.  Moreover, videoconference technology limits the ability of the jury or the fact finder from viewing all aspects of witnesses’ persona to determine veracity.  Crafty witnesses can hide fidgeting, reading a script and other important aspects of testimony from their cameras.  Weighing credibility is especially important to employment litigation which frequently involves “he said-she said” testimony.  

Whether SB 241 becomes law or not, courtrooms will continue to use technology to increase the speed at which dockets may be cleared.  The legislature has until September 10, 2021 to pass some version of SB 241 or it becomes a dead letter.  If SB 241 becomes law, CDF will update you with additional details.

About CDF

For over 25 years, CDF has distinguished itself as one of the top employment, labor and immigration firms in California, representing employers in single-plaintiff and class action lawsuits and advising employers on related legal compliance and risk avoidance. We cover the state, with five locations from Sacramento to San Diego.

> visit primary site

About the Editor in Chief

Sacramento Office Managing Partner and Chair of CDF’s Traditional Labor Law Practice Group. Mark has been practicing labor and employment law in California for thirty years. His practice has a special emphasis on the representation of California employers in union-management relations and handling federal and state court litigation and administrative matters triggered by all types of employment-related disputes. He is also adept at providing creative and practical legal advice to help minimize the risks inherent in employing workers in California. He recently named “Sacramento Lawyer of the Year” in Employment Law-Management for 2021 by Best Lawyers®.
> Full Bio   > Email   Call 916.361.0991

CDF Labor Law LLP © 2021

Editorial Board About CDF What We Do Contact Us Attorney Advertising Disclaimer Privacy Policy Cookie Policy